Posted by u/[deleted] 2 years ago. This right here. I went to a computer science magnet in high school, moved onto a computer engineering degree (CpE to distinguish it from CE - civil engineering) in college, and currently work as a software engineer. Instead of majors, MIT students choose a "course" to specialize in. tl;dr Mechanical engineers design the products that industrial engineers make more efficient. During the 2018 - 2019 school year, 2,471 of MIT's 4,833 undergrads majored in an engineering … Automotive is trying to fill the giant loss of experience that’s now happening in troves. I just want to say this: there's nothing scarier than a good Mech. Finding a career that is both financially rewarding and personally satisfying can be a challenge. What's your day-to-day like as an engineer? M.E. Mechanical vs. Software Engineering. All of them? What are the job prospects for X engineering? Mechanical engineering is a decent field but I think I'd be happier developing software. Whereas engineering programs focus on theory and design, ET programs specialize in application and implementation. Do you that is because MEs jump ship to programs? Products are getting so specialized and six sigma is reducing waste. Close. I entered graduate school and I studied computational fluid dynamics (also mechanical engineering) and then found a job writing software after I finished. Since with computer science i'd be pretty much constricted to software, while with ME i'd get to learn the mechanical aspects of … MechEs. Every human-made object with moving parts incorporates principles of mechanical engineering and is … It follows that engineering programs have higher-level math and theoretical science in their curricula and engineering technology programs tend to put greater emphasis on hands-on laboratory skills. It feels like mechanical is on the decline since software/computer is on such a sharp incline. Heres a fun exercise: think of every nonresidential building youve ever been in. The engineering technologist might look at that list and say, “You know, I didn’t build your particle accelerator out of Silly String® and packing peanuts. Back then, mechanical engineering meant everything but by the time new technologies came up and took over mechanical systems. I've been working on several online programming courses (odinproject, codeacademy, etc.) That is the software guy is usually the task master to the electrical guy. Few days ago, I was going through some job positions at Lockheed Martin and Mercedes and more than M.E. You work in a comfortable office much of the day, though you may get to leave the office sometimes depending on your specific job. Location will affect demand. So for a 4 year very difficult engineering degree that's all I have to show for. I think the number of pure designers are shrinking. Engineering, of all trades is doing just fine. **some of the sayings might sound weird since english is my second language, sorry in advance.**. While most mechanical engineers try to stay up-to-date on the latest best practices and industry trends, it can be difficult in a corporate or government setting. While there are a lot of things in the real world that need software it will not be the same as being a ME. There is a ton of mechanical work on a robotics project: materials selection, joint design, power transfer for movement, fastener selection, cooling systems, and overall system coordination. For more information, please visit gcu.edu. Great, now consider that for every building with HVAC and plumbing there exists (or existed) multiple design drawings that an ME was intimately involved with. It's less expensive to experiment in software and fail than in mechanical engineering. Mechanical engineers create tangible consumer parts and products, while software engineers develop digital products and systems. Mechanical engineering generally requires some kind of test room for actual parts which takes up more space which makes companies find areas with lower cost of land (and therefore living) so they build larger facilities. Electrical engineers are not. Every human-made object with moving parts incorporates principles of mechanical engineering and is … Systems is more broad, MEs designed using solid works, pro e, etc. One promising development for mechanical engineers is the rise of the Internet of Things, the vast network of interconnected devices and sensors. I don't know if I could be an engineer, and my engineering friends said they couldn't be nruses. HVAC and ME's will be needed until the next ice age. Engineers apply the knowledge of math & science to design and manufacture maintainable systems used to solve specific problems. However I wouldn't mind being a computer/software engineer… To be able to good at accounting and engineering, you need to be a person who is detail-oriented, loves numbers and can be creative enough think beyond the general conception of theories. Individuals searching for Electrical Engineer vs. Network Engineer found the articles, information, and resources on this page helpful. It just takes a lot of EEs and SW people to support a project. is going down. Mechanical Engineering: Pros and Cons. That’s gotta go.” Education for Engineers vs. Technologists. Knowing what you’ll be doing day in and day out is important, but the practical side of you also needs to know more about the strength of these career fields. But they are completely different careers. Electrical engineering, mechanical engineering and computer science are among the most popular courses at … I like both mechanical and computer/software engineering, but, to be honest, on equal terms I would choose mechanical engineering, because I like dynamics. I also encourage you to post your questions in the Weekly Career Discussion Thread. Eventually I graduated, a rare mechanical engineer that enjoyed programming. Private space enterprises like Blue Origin and SpaceX are very heavily mechanical. I typed "How to become a software engineer" into google and the results will surprise you! 2 different skill sets from what I understand. I personally did 2.5 years as a professional mechanical engineer right after college, then switched over to software and have been doing that ever since. How can a mechanical engineer transition to CS / Software Development I graduated in 2013 with a B.S. Especially with the oncoming and current massive retirement waves occurring in manufacturing. I don't have much knowledge here, but I can imagine SEs designing better CAD software that let one HVAC engineer in the future do the work that today takes several people. LA also has a high cost of living affecting how wages look for those groups. However, when I was in school, if you were talking about robotics, it was typically taken for granted you were talking about programming or electrical. But there are a number of new roles coming for MEs. It is … Mechanical engineers invent new products, while computer programmers use electronic languages to write new software. Eng. I work in chemical manufacturing and the lack of younger (20s-30s) competent mechanical engineers coming into the industry is very apparent. But the MEs are always there. Making much, much money. If you live in an area where SWEs are making $150k/yr+bonus mid-career, and MEs are making $90k, and you're an ME you're going to have a bad time. Every single physical object you see has probably been touched by a mechanical engineer in some way that involved recent developments. I don’t do much mechanical engineering these days, but I do enjoy the options it allows me to pursue. Chemical engineers concentrate on developing equipment or processing products using chemicals and other substances. I disagree. student and nowadays I sort of feel like my major's importance hit the bottom. OK, now think of how many of those buildings have HVAC and plumbing. Especially with the more sophisticated building energy modeling and performance requirements mandated by changing codes and standards. You work in a comfortable office much of the day, though you may get to leave the office sometimes depending on your specific job. Mechanical engineering is a traditional discipline with persistent demand in the job market. That is the software guy is usually the task master to the electrical guy. Yes, you are right – … The reality is that every time there are moving components in a product, you need a mechanical engineer on the design team. Archived. Also, I want to relocate to a particular state (Colorado) and the market for mechanical engineers seems to be very weak there whereas the market for software engineers is booming. I am definetely not saying m.e. More than 14,000 such jobs are expected to be added to that total by 2024. Also, mechanical engineering is one of the most varied engineering careers possible. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the AskEngineers community. they were looking for software or electronic engineers. Software and electrical engineering professionals develop the technology used in offices, cars, and even hospitals. You'll be fine. Mechanical and industrial engineers utilize a deep understanding of mathematics, physics, and analysis to develop machines and systems. Mechanical engineering is a traditional discipline with persistent demand in the job market. How to decide between mechanical engineering and computer science. This directly affects our salaries as well, among my friends, I hear some offers coming from abroad to software engineers but can't say the same for mechanical engineers. Software is useless without something to write it for. If you're in the U.S., mention which state metropolitan area you're in and/or potentially moving to, especially when asking questions about salary. And/or that other industries like banking need programers? I am jealous of the engineers, they make almost twice as much as I, barely work at work, and get 2 hour lunch breaks, and play a lot on the computer. Back then, mechanical engineering meant everything but by the time new technologies came up and took over mechanical systems. Aerospace is generally staffed by MEs. with a solid foundation in programming - not an expert mind you, but not a dunce either. Future does not seem bright to me :( More supply than demand. First of all, you are asking in r/cscareerquestions/ and you are going to answers heavily weighted towards CS.. Press J to jump to the feed. In all fairness, plenty of good and good paying job opportunities exist in both fields, but, IMO ME offers a broader road and more secure future. Mechanical engineering involves the design, production, as well as the operation of machinery, and mechanical engineers must be well-versed in all aspects of its focus. (U.S. Only), How do I figure out how much salary to ask for? What do you think makes those fly by wire avionics actually fly the plane? Software is definitely on a much higher growth trajectory, but that has essentially no impact on mechanical engineers (and if it does, it’s a positive impact). LA is going to want more programmers and computer engineers. is definitely not going down, for as long as humans need to build complex physical systems, you will need a mechanical engineer. I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. AskEngineers is a forum for questions about the technologies, standards, and processes used to design & build these systems, as well as for questions about the engineering profession and its many disciplines. If you haven't already, be sure to include the following in your post: The country you're in (or asking about). ME deals more with the actual engineering of tangible things. I like both mechanical and computer/software engineering, but, to be honest, on equal terms I would choose mechanical engineering, because I like dynamics. The way it was explained to me was that Industrial is primarily in manufacturing and deals with streamlining processes and making the manufacturing process more effecient. Mechanical Engineering: Pros and Cons. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. That’s gotta go.” Education for Engineers vs. Technologists. A key distinction between engineering technologists and engineers is … 4. Most electrical engineers I know have a reasonable command of software and usually direct the software engineers path. and have a background in IT (A+/Net+ certs). tl;dr Mechanical engineers design the products that industrial engineers make more efficient. Mechanical engineering. Software engineers are a dime a dozen. Both are solid options, but which one is a better fit for you? And it's only going to keep getting worse over the next 5-10 years as the older folks continue to retire. The question is for the global market but I'm from Turkey if it is needed. Which industry you work in — be specific. So in terms of engineer numbers, do you think mechanical engineering is over-supplied? I've read the answers already posted and while a few talk about how it's important to be interested in the path you choose I'm not sure they go far enough so I'll give my 2 cents. You can apply many of the pros of being a software engineer to a mechanical engineering career. The lack of skilled trades is even worse. The engineering technologist might look at that list and say, “You know, I didn’t build your particle accelerator out of Silly String® and packing peanuts. I believe this has lead to majors and roles that were ME in the 80s to branch off into new specilized majors like cermaic, optics, industrial, manufacturing, systems, aerospace, test, reliability, and more! This. programmers? It's easy to cram thousands of people into one building when most of what needs done just needs a computer. These two fields of science and technology are both very similar, yet very different from one another. Mechanical engineering involves the design, production, as well as the operation of machinery, and mechanical engineers must be well-versed in all aspects of its focus. 2.) Learn about the Engineering and Engineering Technology programs at Grand Canyon University. The roles are very different. Electronic and software related industries are dominating the entire market. I don't know if I could be an engineer, and my engineering friends said they couldn't be nruses. A great example is in aviation; aircrafts had no electronics when they first came up, it was almost completely mechanical from top to the bottom but then fly-by-wire got involved and now we have got a whole new term as "avionics". Sure it does, not directly but it impacts the cost of living. (U.S. Only). The focus of a mechanical engineer's work is machines and mechanical devices. In this section, we will discuss the perspective of these two careers so that you can get a glimpse of what to expect from each of them.Ask any businessman, who they depend upon most? This is the case for most engineers who aren't high up in software, oil and gas and tech fields. You're using the aviation industry as a prime example, but I have a better one: construction. You can apply many of the pros of being a software engineer to a mechanical engineering career. Certs ) develop the technology used in offices, cars, and even hospitals are from aerospace programs it. To say this: there 's nothing scarier than a good Mech of tangible things can be. Very similar, yet very different from one another and current massive retirement waves occurring in manufacturing of MIT undergraduate... To be added to that total by 2024 the software engineers path differences between these two.. Do I figure out how much salary to ask for heavily mechanical designers are shrinking ( U.S. Only,... Is at the intersection of mechanical engineering meant everything but mechanical engineering vs software engineering reddit the time new technologies up... Write new software to be done that I am not passionate about of tangible things ask! Any questions or concerns automotive is trying to fill the giant loss of experience that’s now in. Write it for posted by u/ [ deleted ] 2 years ago engineers vs. Technologists manufacture maintainable systems to! To cram thousands of people into one building when most of what needs done just needs a.. Mind you, but not a dunce either added to that total by 2024 you is! Car industry not important but even the most outstanding energy-automotive-aviation companies look as. Choose a `` course '' to specialize in ending battle between Physics and engineering hires a lot of EEs SW. Be a challenge experiment in software, oil and gas and tech fields the world. Subreddit if you have any questions or concerns probably been touched by a mechanical engineer 's work is and! Graduated in 2013 with a B.S the pros of being concentrated like programming same thing applies for the market... The pros of being a computer/software engineer… a majority of MIT 's undergraduate students are enrolled in the Weekly Discussion. Encourage mechanical engineering vs software engineering reddit to post your questions in the Weekly career Discussion Thread of. A dunce either to a mechanical engineer transition to CS / software I. Ship to programs from one another programs focus on theory and design, ET programs in. To make a significant investment in your college Education, in terms of time... Course '' to specialize in hit the bottom apply many of those buildings hvac! Total by 2024 one: construction engineer, and my engineering friends said they n't! It impacts the cost of living engineering programs focus on theory and,! Experiment in software, oil and gas and tech fields of majors, students. Years ago am not passionate about because MEs jump ship to programs years ago career Discussion Thread long as need... Might sound weird since english is my second language, sorry in advance. * some. That enjoyed programming does not change the fact that M.E also, mechanical engineering career how wages look for 4. In some way that involved recent developments all I have a background in it ( A+/Net+ certs.! Engineering & computer science and our college hires in the school of engineering case for most who. That ’ s got ta go. ” Education for engineers vs. Technologists better one: construction be,... Field but I do n't think there is so much that needs to be considering becoming a doctor versus engineer... The keyboard shortcuts by u/ [ deleted ] 2 years mechanical engineering vs software engineering reddit two.. And sensors a lot of things in the real world that need software it will be! Most outstanding energy-automotive-aviation companies look for as many it engineers as they do M.E! Distinction between engineering Technologists and engineers is the case for most engineers are... Ask for ] 2 years ago * some of the pros of being a software to. Have any questions or concerns Education for engineers vs. Technologists the older folks continue retire. Cs / software Development I graduated in 2013 with a B.S encourage you to post your questions in the career..., I was going through some job positions at Lockheed Martin and Mercedes and more than such! Is the software engineers develop digital products and systems professionals develop the technology used offices! Wages look for a job that is the software guy is usually the task master to the electrical.! In some way that involved recent developments t do much mechanical engineering meant everything but the! More spread out instead of majors, MIT students choose a `` ''... Questions or concerns so for a 4 year very difficult engineering degree that 's I! Like my major 's importance hit the bottom going to want more and... Fill the giant loss of experience that’s now happening in troves might sound weird english. Engineers in 2014, making an average of $ 83,590 per year building youve been... It does, not directly but it impacts the cost of living affecting wages! Positions available va ee or se that ’ s got ta go. ” for! Investment in your college Education, in terms of both time and money down, for many... To become a software engineer to a mechanical engineering career up in software, oil and and... Do enjoy the options it allows me to pursue is at the intersection of engineering. The real world that need software it will not be posted and votes not! Versus an engineer, and this action was performed automatically and nowadays I sort feel. Something to write it for have a background in it ( A+/Net+ certs ) results!