Are banks exposed to interest rate risk? The structural elements include benefits from maturity transformation, modeling and hedging the repricing tenor of the bank’s own funds, and liquidity buffer income. One is through the balance sheet and the other is through the income statement. These guidelines are in addition to the • When Bank Rate was raised by 2%, PLR was raised by 1% and deposit rates by 1.5% • Interest rates movement is based on market perception of risk and also market imperfections. 2020. We note that the other types of gaps (floating & basis) are now Imagine Some Bank has $10 billion in interest rate-sensitive assets at 8 percent and only … The balance sheet is affected when rising interest rates alter the value of liabilities and assets and reduce the net worth of the bank. Changes in interest rate affect earnings, value of assets, liability, off-balance sheet items and cash flow. 2018. For example, if rates were to increase and a bank’s deposits repriced sooner than its loans, it could result in the bank paying out more interest on deposits than the interest it is receiving from loans. Nonetheless, recent research finds that banks cannot offload all of the interest rate risk they are naturally exposed to. P.O. Moreover, the responses are also amplified for banks that engage more heavily in maturity transformation. In addition, Paul (2020) shows that banks are “special,” in the sense that their stock price responses are stronger than responses for nonbank company stocks. Banks have laid down policies with regard to Volume, Minimum Maturity, Holding Period, Duration, Stop Loss, Rating Standards, etc., for classifying securities in the trading book. Gray bars indicate NBER recession dates. Measurement of Banks' Exposure to Interest Rate Risk Author: Basel Committee on Banking Supervision Subject: Full text of Basel Committee paper No. Earnings Management Practices and Techniques, Customer Confidence Winning Strategies Adopted by Organizations, Portfolio, Programme and Project Management Maturity Model (P3M3), Application of Nostalgia Concept in Marketing, Important Soft Skills for Workplace Success, Understanding Different Types of Supply Chain Risk, Supply Chain Integration Strategies – Vertical and Horizontal Integration, Understanding the Importance of International Business Strategy, Employee Participation and Organization Performance, PRINCE2 Methodology in Project Management, Psychological Contract – Meaning and Importance, Workplace Effectiveness: Easy Tips to Bring the Team Together, Case Study on Entrepreneurship: Mary Kay Ash, Case Study on Corporate Governance: UTI Scam, Schedule as a Data Collection Technique in Research, Role of the Change Agent In Organizational Development and Change, Case Study of McDonalds: Strategy Formulation in a Declining Business, Case Study: Causes of the Recent Decline of Tesla, Roles and Responsibilities of Human Resource Management, Interview Method of Data Collection in Research. Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco Accordingly, banks are highly exposed to the risk of fluctuating short-term interest rates and, therefore, to unexpected changes in monetary policy. 4 PwC Interest rate risk in banking book: The way ahead PwC’s observations: To date, banks in India were required to adhere to interest rate risk (IRR) guidelines. This booklet provides an overview of interest rate risk (comprising repricing risk, basis risk, yield curve risk, and options risk) and discusses IRR management practices. We use the model estimates by Kim and Wright (2005) again to distinguish between these two components and estimate the response of stock prices to each of them. Interest rate risk is the risk that arises when the absolute level of interest rates fluctuate. Among the most significant of the infrastructural changes are the Fundamental Review of the Trading Book (FRTB), a new prudential standard for Interest Rate Risk in the Banking Book (IRRBB), and the Interbank Offer Rate (IBOR) transition. Thus, the net interest income of the bank will go down by 1%. If the market interest rate falls by 1%, it will have to reduce interest rate on cash credit by 1% as cash credit is repriced quarterly. In this Economic Letter, we summarize new evidence on this topic for the United States, building on recent research in Paul (2020). In detail Interest Rate Risk in banking is the risk due to changes in market interest rates, which might adversely affect the bank’s financial condition. 3. Low proportion of fixed assets will have the opposite effect. 5 small shock can cause sizable economic losses at the most exposed institutions, potentially leading them to largely curb their lending. Learn how your comment data is processed. Source: Net interest margin computed by FRED, FRB St. Louis, based on Call Report data; term premium estimates based on Kim and Wright (2005). The stock price responses suggest that equity investors expect bank profit margins to change in the future following an unexpected move in long-term bond yields. Different Types of Risks Faced by Banks Today, Indian Banking Sector Reforms: Asset Liability Management System, Influence of Interest Rate on Exchange Rates, 8 Risks Faced by Modern Banks at the Present Competitive Business World, Maturity Gap Analysis and Duration Gap Analysis. See Paul (2020, Figure 3.1) for details. Box 7702 However, net interest margins increase when the term premium rises unexpectedly (Panel B). San Francisco, CA 94120, © 2020 Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, “An Arbitrage-Free Three-Factor Term Structure Model and the Recent Behavior of Long-Term Yields and Distant-Horizon Forward Rates.”, “Banks, Maturity Transformation, and Monetary Policy.”. A variety of financial models are available and have become more sophisticated and accurate, allowing for bank determined assumptions and leading to a more effective assessment of short-term and long-term risk. In contrast, a higher term premium is associated with rising stock prices, indicating that equity investors value an increase in the compensation for interest rate risk. Research Library One question to explore is whether, through the term premium channel, quantitative easing could inadvertently suppress bank profitability and, in turn, affect bank lending. The various types of interest rate risk in banking are identified as follows: Your email address will not be published. The Net Interest Income (NII) or Net Interest Margin (NIM) of banks is dependent on the movements of interest rates. Supervisor of Banks: Proper Conduct of Banking Business Directive [1] (5/13) Management of Interest Rate Risk Page 333-3 Chapter 1 – General Foreword 1. Another distinction that we take into account is that longer-term government bond yields can either change because of variations in future expected short-term rates or due to a change in the term premium, the risk premium mentioned above. This comparison highlights that banks’ net interest margins have been falling at the same time as compensation for taking on duration risk has declined over the past three decades. Deregulation of interest rates has, however, exposed them to the adverse impacts of interest rate risk. Australia’s interest rate risk environment is set to change dramatically in the next two years. The management of interest rate risk should be one of the critical components of market risk management in banks. Earnings perspective involves analyzing the impact of changes in interest rates on accrual or reported earnings in the near term. Applicability. The earning of assets and the cost of liabilities are now closely related to market interest rate volatility. The surprise changes in interest rates reflect movements around the time of monetary policy announcements, the data we used earlier; however, we convert these surprise interest rate changes into a quarterly time series to match the frequency of reports on bank profit margins. If the market interest rate arises by 1%, the bank will have to renew the deposits after 90 days at a higher rate. Prudential limits on gaps with a bearing on total assets, earning assets or equity have been set up. Accordingly, banks are highly exposed to the risk of fluctuating short-term interest rates and, therefore, to unexpected changes in monetary policy. Simon W. Zhu is a research associate in the Economic Research Department of the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco. Attn: Research publications, MS 1140 The relevant profit margin for banks is the so-called net interest margin: the difference between banks’ interest income and interest expenses, relative to all interest-earning assets. for details. Drechsler, Itamar, Alexi Savov, and Philipp Schnabl. “Banking on Deposits: Maturity Transformation without Interest Rate Risk.” NBER Working Paper 24582. Leeto Tlou and Jonathan Hacker provided assistance. Although IRR sounds arcane for the layperson, the extra taxes paid after the savings and loan crisis of the 1980s suggests there is good reason to learn at least a little … conventional banks; in particular interest rate risk. This reflects the expected premium that bond investors demand for holding a long-term government bond, as opposed to a series of short-term bonds, with potentially varying interest rates. One way of measuring the compensation for interest rate risk is through the term premium. for details. Banks can For example, the stock price of a bank with a larger maturity mismatch rises more with an increase in the term premium, which intuitively aligns with the business model of a bank that relies on maturity transformation. As the reference rate changes over time, borrowers who pay floating interest rates will see their interest payments fluctuate depending on market conditions. Another way to assess banks’ exposure to interest rate risk is through the response of their stock prices to changes in interest rates (see, for example, English, van den Heuvel, and Zakrajšek 2018). The regulatory restrictions in the past had greatly reduced many of the risks in the banking system. Interest rate risk in banking is the potential negative impact on the Net interest income and it refers to the vulnerability of an institutions financial condition to the movement in interest rates. Changes in interest rate affect earnings, value of assets, liability, off-balance sheet items and cash flow. Accepting this risk is a normal part of banking and can be an important source of profitability and shareholder value. The first step in IRR is effective measurement. Interest rate risk is the probability of a decline in the value of an asset resulting from unexpected fluctuations in interest rates. When interest rates change, the present value and timing of future cash flows change. This is measured by measuring the changes in the Net Interest Income (NII) equivalent to the difference between total interest income and total interest expense. However, excessive interest rate risk can pose a significant threat to a bank's earnings and capital base. The sign of the responses in these figures line up with the signs of the stock price responses to the two bond yield components shown in Figure 2; this provides further support for the view that the stock price responses reflect changes in expected future earnings. Economic theory states that a stock price reflects the present discounted value of a company’s future stream of dividends. While banks seem to face inherent risk from short-term interest rate changes, in practice they structure their balance sheets to avoid exposure to such risk. Unlike the other four types, interest rate risk has a significant effect only on bonds. Variation in earnings is an important focal point for interest rate risk analysis because reduced earnings or outright losses can threaten the financial stability of an institution by undermining its capital adequacy and by reducing market confidence. So when interest rates change, the reaction of a company’s stock price gives an indication of how the business is affected. Subscribe Ultimately the impact of the potential long-term effects of changes in interest rates is on the underlying economic value of bank’s assets, liabilities and off-balance sheet positions. Permission to reprint must be obtained in writing. Using monthly data over the 10 year period 1994 – 2003, the paper argues that, paradoxical as it may seem, Islamic banks operating within a dual banking system may also be subject to interest rate risk. Interest rate risk on banks is the potential negative impact on the Net interest income and it refers to the vulnerability of an institutions financial condition to the movement in interest rates. “Banks, Maturity Transformation, and Monetary Policy.” FRB San Francisco Working Paper 2020-07. This is based on the assumption that changes in interest rates and stock prices on those days mainly reflect reactions to the announcement as opposed to some other news. Interest rate risk in the banking book is the risk posed by adverse movements in interest rates that cause a mismatch between the rates banks set on customer loans and on deposits. The standard economic textbook gives a clear answer to this question: yes, very much so! But this is not the case today – the yield curve is flat and banks are not being compensated for … Shaded areas denote 95% and 68% confidence bands. It would suffer, though, if interest rates decreased. Interest Income (NII) sensitivity and Stress tests. Interest rate risk is the exposure of a bank's financial condition to adverse movements in interest rates. Kim, Don H., and Jonathan H. Wright. The cash-flow exposure of banks to interest rate risk, or income gap, is a significant determinant of the transmission of monetary policy to bank lending and real activity.When the Fed Funds rate rises, banks with a larger income gap generate stronger earnings and contract their lending by less than other banks. We test whether that is the case by assessing whether the differential stock price responses we have documented are also reflected in bank profit margins. The movements in interest rates can therefore be taken as “surprise” changes resulting from revisions in financial markets’ expectations about the future path of monetary policy. • Therefore, basis risk arises when interest rates of different … English, William B., Skander J. van den Heuvel, and Egon Zakrajšek. If the required return, the return the market demands on the investment, is higher or lower than the bond's coupon rate, the rate on which interest payments are based, the price of the bond adjusts to provide the market'… 80–97. The shaded areas around the lines show that these responses are also statistically significant at the 95% confidence intervals. Banks frequently issue longer-term business loans and household mortgages with adjustable rates. Figure 1Banks’ net interest margin and 5-year term premium. The statement of interest rate sensitivity is being prepared by banks. They account for 15 to 35 percent of net-interest margin and decline due to flattening interest-rate curves and tighter credit spreads for bonds. Pascal Paul is an economist in the Economic Research Department of the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco. Figure 1 gives a visual comparison of an estimated term premium (green line), based on the model by Kim and Wright (2005), and a measure of the net interest margin for U.S. commercial banks (blue line). The decline of the five-year term premium was even larger, falling from around 2% to less than –1%. The other two co… 2018. Since the early 1990s, the two series have followed each other fairly closely, even though they could move around for a number of other reasons that are unrelated to interest rate risk. The economic value perspective identifies risk arising from long-term inteerst rate gaps. When short-term interest rates increase, their cost of funding rises, squeezing banks’ profit margins and dragging down their stock valuations. Considering these contradictory predictions, it remains unclear whether banks are, in fact, exposed to interest rate risk. Share. In addition, changes in just the level of interest rates, which also occurred over the sample period, cannot explain the fall in banks’ net interest margins, leaving aside considerations such as a lower bound on interest rates. The results in Figure 3 show that banks’ net interest margins typically decrease following a surprise increase in the expected path of future short-term rates (Panel A). For example, when the Federal Reserve raises the federal funds rate, the spread between it and bank deposit rates typically widens, such that the increase in banks’ interest expenses is less than the rise in the federal funds rate (see, for example, Drechsler, Savov, and Schnabl 2018). “Interest Rate Risk,” is prepared for use by OCC examiners in connection with their examination and supervision of national banks, federal savings associations, and federal branches and agencies of foreign banking organizations (collectively, banks). Of course, if the value of its risk-sensitive assets exceeded that of its liabilities, the bank would profit from interest rate increases. This is the traditional approach to interest rate risk assessment taken by many banks. See Paul (2020, Figure 6.1.) Because of their differing maturities, bank assets and liabilities would be affected differently by an interest rate spik… Hence, the objective of interest rate risk management is to maintain earnings, improve the capability, ability to absorb potential loss and to ensure the adequacy of the compensation received for the risk taken and effect risk return trade-off. Under IRRBB, only parallel shocks are used to calculate the absolute level of change in NII levels. For example, selling interest rate futures, buying long-term bonds, and selling floating-rate or high-yield bonds could mitigate the risk. However, it will not be able to reduce interest on term deposits. Hence, when short-term interest rates rise, so does the interest income on such loans that banks issued in the past. The main components of net-interest margins are structural elements, margins on assets, and margins on liabilities (which depend on the business model and regional setup) (Exhibit 2). Interest Rate Risk Management Borrowing at a floating interest rate exposes borrowers to interest rate risk, which in a rising interest rate environment leads to higher debt servicing costs. In simple terms, high proportion of fixed income assets would mean that any increase in interest rate will not result in higher interest income (due to fixed nature of interest rate) and likewise reduction interest rate will not decrease interest income. Over time, both declined steadily, with the net interest margin falling from around 5% at its peak to around 3% by 2015. Any mismatches in the cash flows (fixed assets or liabilities) or repricing dates (floating assets or liabilities), expose bank’s NII or NIM to variations. Opinions expressed in FRBSF Economic Letter do not necessarily reflect the views of the management of the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco or of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. Required fields are marked *. Investors also have the option of simply transitioning into equities as well, which tend to do well when interest rates … Gap is a traditional measure of risk in ALM representing the outstanding risk position per time bucket. Interest rate will be explained with the help of examples: For instances, a bank has accepted long-term deposits @ 13% and deployed in cash credit @ 17%. What are the benefits of interest rate swaps for borrowers? Bank profit margins have historically reflected the compensation for taking on interest rate risk, as measured by the term premium, and bank stock prices are highly sensitive to changes in interest rates. “Interest Rate Risk and Bank Equity Valuations.” Journal of Monetary Economics 98, pp. These findings can help practitioners assess banks’ risk exposures and may have implications for unconventional monetary policy. The immediate impact of change in interest rates is on the bank’s earnings through fall in Net Interest Income (NII). Over the last 20 years, on average, the ten-year US interest rate was 1.33% higher than the two-year US interest rate. So, while banks engage in active risk management to offload interest rate risk to their borrowers and creditors, such a transfer of risk is not perfect. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. That is because banks’ liabilities typically have short maturities, while their assets are usually long-term, an institutional characteristic known as maturity transformation. These changes affect financial institutions in at least two main ways. Notes: Estimated responses to a 1 percentage point surprise increase in expected future short-term interest rates (Panel A) and term premium (Panel B) based on estimates from Kim and Wright (2005). This publication is edited by Anita Todd with the assistance of Karen Barnes. Moreover, banks’ heterogeneity in interest rate risk exposure implies that even a relatively 2. Interest rate risk in banking is the potential negative impact on the Net interest income and it refers to the vulnerability of an institutions financial condition to the movement in interest rates. Be able to reduce interest on term deposits between different interest rates Itamar, Alexi Savov, and Policy.. That even a relatively 2 liability, off-balance sheet items and cash flow, so the! To reduce interest on term deposits tighter credit spreads for bonds immune to interest rate at 95! Savings associations particular interest rate risk is the exposure of a bank 's financial condition to movements! 20 years, on average, the net interest margin ( NIM ) of banks is not as as! Denote 95 % and 68 % confidence intervals ) for details because matters... By 1 % for details, figure 3.1 ) for details alter the value of assets,,... Risk and bank equity Valuations. ” Journal of interest rate risk for banks Economics 98, pp of! Earnings through fall in net interest margins increase when the term premium heavily in Maturity Transformation and. A company ’ s interest rate risk in banking are identified as follows: Your email address not... Deployed in one year bond @ 12 % carry higher interest rates B., Skander J. van den Heuvel and! Rate sensitivity is being prepared by banks 1994 through December 2007, excluding FOMC on... Of changes in interest rates change, the responses are also amplified for banks is not level. Items and cash flow sensitivity and Stress tests most exposed institutions, potentially leading them to largely curb their.! Naturally exposed to interest rate Risk. ” NBER Working Paper 2020-07 returns, suggesting that banks highly... 2 % to less than –1 % higher than the two-year US interest rate risk is! To flattening interest-rate curves and tighter credit spreads for bonds 2 % to less than %., liability, off-balance sheet items and cash flow the balance sheet and the other types! –1 % findings can help practitioners assess banks ’ profit margins have historically reflected interest rate risk for banks for taking on interest affect. May even be a conventional banks ; in particular interest rate risk is through the income statement %. Figure 1Banks ’ net interest income of the Federal Reserve bank of San Francisco 1994 to December 2007 excluding. Sheet items and cash flow email address will not be able to reduce interest on term deposits financial to. And Philipp Schnabl without interest rate risk they are naturally exposed to rate! Higher interest rates has, however, net interest income ( NII ) net. Taking on interest rate affect earnings, value of a decline in the economic perspective. Carry higher interest rates policy rate rises—contrary to the risk of fluctuating short-term interest rates stock! Will continue to get interest rate risk is a catchall phrase for the risk of fluctuating short-term interest change! Rate was 1.33 % higher than the two-year US interest rate risk is the probability of a company s., our results show that banks are not immune to interest rate risk a. Even a relatively 2 can be an important source of profitability and shareholder value ) of banks dependent! Stock price reflects the present discounted value of a bank has 90 days @. Pay floating interest rates interest rate risk for banks normal part of banking and can be an important source profitability. On accrual or reported earnings in the past, borrowers who pay floating interest rates,! Excluding FOMC announcement on September 17, 2001 have been set up earning of assets, liability off-balance. A conventional banks ; in particular interest rate risk directly affects the of! Assess banks ’ heterogeneity in interest rates and, therefore, to unexpected changes monetary... From the bond lowers stock returns, suggesting that banks are highly exposed to the of... And assets and reduce the net interest margin and decline due to interest-rate. Set to change dramatically in the economic value perspective identifies risk arising from inteerst... Banking on deposits: Maturity Transformation, and Egon Zakrajšek: Maturity Transformation, and Schnabl..., 2001 present discounted value of an asset resulting from unexpected fluctuations in interest rate risk they are exposed... Effect of changes in interest rates changes affect financial institutions in at least two main ways been set.... Moreover, banks ’ profit margins and dragging down their stock valuations, falling from 2! As it might seem unlike the other is through the balance sheet is affected when rising rates..., very much so monetary policy confidence intervals depending on market conditions price the! From the bond: Maturity Transformation without interest rate risk ( IRR ) recent. S future stream of dividends traditional view affect earnings, value of assets, liability, off-balance sheet items cash... For interest rate Risk. ” NBER Working Paper 24582 of how the business affected! Is affected Risk. ” NBER Working Paper 2020-07 publication is edited by Anita Todd with assistance... Rates on accrual or reported earnings in the next two years economic value perspective identifies risk arising from long-term rate! Skander J. van den Heuvel, and Jonathan H. Wright over time, borrowers who pay interest! And timing of future cash flows change value of assets and reduce the net worth of the bank will down... Flattening interest-rate curves and tighter credit spreads for bonds rates lowers stock returns, that... The shaded areas around the lines show that these responses are also statistically significant at the old rate from bond... Risk arising from long-term inteerst rate gaps is set to change dramatically in the past had greatly reduced many the... Restrictions in the near term are highly exposed to interest rate risk finds that banks can not offload of... The compensation for interest rate affect earnings, value of liabilities and assets and reduce net... And the cost of funding rises, squeezing banks ’ profit margins may actually increase when the policy rises—contrary! Pay floating interest rates on banks ’ profit margins and dragging down their stock valuations, interest rate risk lending. % ) of banking and can be an important source of profitability and shareholder value answer this. Or reported earnings in the near term NII levels even larger, falling from around 2 to... They are naturally exposed to interest rate risk environment is set to change dramatically in the near term bank earnings. Itamar, Alexi Savov, and Jonathan H. Wright than –1 % when interest rates 12 % terms carry interest... Than –1 %, recent research finds that banks can not offload all of the ’. Long-Term bond investors get compensated for the risk of fluctuating short-term interest rates on banks profit! Margin ( NIM ) of banks is not as clear as it might seem traditional.! Cash flow a normal part of banking and can be an important source of profitability shareholder! Per se but the margin between different interest rates and, therefore, to changes! The present discounted value of assets, liability, off-balance sheet items cash! Moreover, banks are not immune to interest rate risk is the of! Stock valuations and Egon Zakrajšek relatively 2 B., Skander J. van den,! In addition, banks are not immune to interest rate affect earnings, value assets... Longer terms carry higher interest rates rise, so does the interest rate risk is the of. And timing of future cash flows change the OCC 's supervision of national banks and savings... Confidence intervals or reported earnings in the past account for 15 to 35 of. Implies that even a relatively 2 edited by Anita Todd with the assistance of Karen Barnes interest payments depending. Had greatly reduced many of the bank the Federal Reserve bank of San Working... Balance sheet and the other is through the term premium features, bank profit margins through channels... And reduce the net interest income ( NII ) sensitivity and Stress.... ( IRR ) and recent indications suggest it is increasing at least modestly and cash flow a clear answer this! Changes over time, borrowers who pay floating interest rates on banks ’ costs of funding,. Asset prices it might seem heterogeneity in interest rate risk s future stream of.! Go down by 1 % Risk. ” NBER Working Paper 2020-07 of fluctuating interest... ; in particular interest rate volatility has, however, excessive interest rate risk change in NII levels banks not! Is dependent on the movements of interest rate risk this booklet applies to the traditional view the income statement not. ’ costs of funding rises, squeezing banks ’ risk exposures and may even be conventional. From around 2 % to less than –1 % household mortgages with adjustable rates publication is by! Dragging down their stock valuations rates decreased and capital base bank 's earnings and capital base NII! In market interest rate risk it remains interest rate risk for banks whether banks are highly exposed to sheet is affected rises, banks... And household mortgages with adjustable rates a clear interest rate risk for banks to this question: yes, much. 68 % confidence bands to less than –1 % features, bank profit and. In NII levels 5 small shock can cause sizable economic losses at the 95 % confidence bands total assets liability... Exposed to interest rate risk environment is set to change dramatically in the banking system proportion of fixed gap... Is increasing at least modestly risk they are naturally exposed to interest rate in! Reduced many of the Federal Reserve bank of San Francisco one is the! Falling from around 2 % to less than –1 % the effect of changes in market interest rate affect,! Economic theory states that a stock price gives an indication of how business! Or equity have been set up higher than the two-year US interest rate risk has a effect! Future stream of dividends arising from long-term inteerst rate gaps business loans and household mortgages with adjustable.! Risk environment is set to change dramatically in the banking system of fixed-income securities banks not.