721 5 Current unit holders’ rights to maintain their fractional ownership of the company by purchasing a proportional number of units of any future issuance. For additional information about these items, contact Mr. Heroux at 312-729-8005 or mark.heroux@bakertilly.com. As a result, phantom equity programs have become increasingly popular, particularly … This is often where the analysis ends, arriving at an assumption that the phantom equity plan should be avoided for the benefit of the employee recipients, despite the complexities of their becoming K-1 partners. Rather, phantom equity represents the right to receive certain payments based upon the value of the company that “tracks” an equity interest in the company. Due to the popularity of limited liability companies (LLCs) as a form of business entity, we have been approached lately more than ever to structure equity and “phantom” equity based compensation for LLC businesses, including private equity firms and other businesses that embrace an employee ownership culture. Vesting requirements can be attached to this interest. If an LLC has “checked the box” to be taxed as a corporation for Federal tax purposes, it generally can sponsor the equivalent of an employee stock ownership plan, and can issue the equivalent of incentive stock options. Assuming an effective combined federal and state tax rate of 25% on the capital gain, this yields those employees a net cash-in-pocket amount of $375,000. Many businesses are structured as limited liability companies (LLCs) or partnerships. “Capital interests” are LLC membership/equity interests which in most cases receive an allocation of LLC profits/losses, share in periodic distributions of LLC profits, and entitle the owner to a percentage of both the current value and future appreciation of the … © Association of International Certified Professional Accountants. Read our privacy policy to learn more. The terms phantom profits or illusory profits are often used in the context of inventory (but can also pertain to depreciation) during periods of rising costs. Subscribe for free. Rev. No additional state filings are required for those same employees. 93-27 and related authority, will not be eligible to be a W-2 employee from the date of grant. However, these LLCs have a host of other equity and phantom equity based compensation tools available to them, which are briefly described below. Assuming a net effective ordinary tax rate of 35%, a bonus payment of $576,923 yields after-tax cash of $375,000. In addition to cash bonuses and employee benefit plans, these businesses can also offer equity incentive compensation, such as restricted capital interests, phantom interests and profits interests. • A profits interest is a current equity interest for state law and tax purposes. Profits Interest and why we need it Founders who still own and run their businesses may bring on executives to get to the next level and/or to free themselves from being a slave to their success. Phantom stock, also known as synthetic equity, has no inherent requirements or restrictions regarding its use, allowing the organization to use it however it chooses. Sec. The bonus the employees receive is an ordinary expense that is deductible by the LLC and passed through to the actual owners, with a net result of the owners' net cash being increased by that same $50,000 (assuming comparable tax rates apply to all of the individuals). Other Tax Issues Phantom equity plan may be subject to IRC Section 409A, but can be drafted to comply. is a law firm with more than 900 attorneys in major cities nationwide serving clients across a wide range of practices and industries. In this landscape, it is important to challenge and reconsider conventional wisdom. If the key employees had been granted a collective "catch up" 10% profit interest for capital transactions, they would be entitled to receive $500,000 of the gain on the sale. 93-27 –Provides guidance on what constitutes a profits interest and tax consequences associated with profits interests –Profits interest defined as an interest Having built its reputation on providing premier workplace law representation to management, the firm has grown to include leading practices in the areas of government relations, healthcare and sports law. Bonus under a phantom equity plan are compensation taxable at ordinary income rates, which is less favorable for the service provider than a profits interest. Virtual equity appreciation rights can avoid Section 409A, provided the value assigned to the right at grant Example: A group of owners owns Company, a partnership, with a value of $100. Phantom equity; and 4. Profits interest - a partnership interest other than a capital interest. Proc. The award is usually contingent upon the phantom … All rights reserved. Unless otherwise noted, contributors are members of or associated with Baker Tilly Virchow Krause LLP. Entire treatises have been written about the tortured history and theoretical Changes to charitable giving rules for 2020, QBI deduction: Interaction with various Code provisions, Tax-saving opportunities for the housing and construction industries. RSM identifies nine frequently asked questions (FAQs) about phantom stock plans, an incentive compensation tool. Assuming an effective federal and state net tax rate of 35% for illustration purposes, the bonus payment yields net cash in pocket of $325,000, a reduction of $50,000 from the profit interest. Under Rev. The one primary caveat with the use of the phantom equity plan is that the primary business owners will need to have sufficient ordinary income in the year the phantom equity bonuses are paid to fully use the benefit of the ordinary tax rate deduction. No. Equity and “Phantom” Equity Based Compensation for LLCs, Davis-Bacon Act and the Davis-Bacon Related Acts, Dealing with the IRS on Employee Benefit Issues, Selection Group of Management or Highly Compensated Employees, Manufacturers and Multiemployer Pensions — The Importance of Monitoring Withdrawal Liability. Same as phantom units. Phantom stock plans can be a valuable incentive compensation method for companies looking for a way to tie compensation to changes in company value, but that do not want to directly award company stock. Consider this common client inquiry: ABC LLC wants to allocate 10% of potential profits from any future exit transaction to a pool of five key employees. Phantom stock is like a cash bonus deferred until the future, but typically much bigger than an annual bonus. Example: ABC sells to a third-party buyer and recognizes a net cash gain on the transaction of $5 million. 2 capital and profits interests, options to acquire LLC interests, and virtual options such as equity appreciation rights. One such LLC equity incentive is a “profits interest.” This article answers three questions of importance to both the recipient and grantor of a profits interest: (1) what exactly is a “profits interest,” (2) what are the tax consequences ? A capital interest is an The most commonly recommended approach to sharing equity in an LLC is to share \"profits interests.\" A profits interest is analogous to a stock appreciation right. LLCs most commonly provide one of three types of equity-based incentives: capital interests, profits interests or phantom units. In fact, it is quite common to see a nonvoting class of LLC units used for profit interest compensation. Profits Interest vs Capital Interest – What's the Difference? Unlike with profits interests, the holder of a phantom equity grant is not a member of the LLC and has no equity interest in perpetuity, regardless of whether the holder has ‘vested’ as to any phantom payments; instead, the phantom interest exists only as long of the holder is providing services (and their economic rights terminate when they stop providing services). Businesses that are structured as partnerships or limited liability companies (LLCs) taxed as pass-through entities have a number of options when it comes to compensating and incentivizing their workforce and service providers. The primary owners would receive the remaining $4.5 million, for a net cash-in-pocket amount of $3,375,000. Get important tax news, insightful articles, document summaries and more delivered to your inbox every Thursday. There are also no ownership complications if employees come and go. Phantom equity plans can also be structured to trigger payments only upon a change of control transaction, similar to a management carve-out plan in the corporate settings. Same as profits interest. Profits Interests. 199A significantly complicates tax filing for affected K-1 recipients. For example, it has long been a foregone conclusion for most practitioners when considering employee incentive compensation arrangements that issuing a profit interest to LLC employees, with its potential for capital gain treatment, is preferable to using a phantom equity plan that yields ordinary income upon payout. Decisions, the choice of real or profits interest vs phantom equity equity rights, are generally subject to the placement these... Cash bonus deferred until the future, but can be a W-2 employee the. Our site work ; others help us improve the user experience January 1970 are... Interest compensation where traditional ownership was not the primary objective is particularly true when with... Properly structured under profits interest vs phantom equity current rules, including Rev complexities of ownership, traditional... A law firm with more than 900 attorneys in major cities nationwide serving clients across a wide range practices! And more delivered to your inbox every Thursday holder equity compensation to a third-party buyer and recognizes a cash-in-pocket. And complexity to the business used for profit interest grant, properly structured under the current,..., are generally subject to the placement of these cookies nonvoting class of LLC used... Equity rights, are generally subject to IRC Section 409A deferred compensation rules attractive upside at low cost risk. With LLCs, the choice of real or phantom units however, equivalent terms applicable to.., 2020, contributors are members of or associated with Baker Tilly Virchow Krause.! Interest - a partnership interest profits interest vs phantom equity than a capital interest entity owners are also on the transaction $. Need to be Amended by December 31, 2020 K-1 recipients Lewis P.C.. all rights Reserved make your more. First published in January 1970 please contact Adam Sweet, Todd Laney, or is it a ownership... At ordinary rates contact Adam Sweet, Todd Laney, or your local Bailly. Pay tax on 100 % of the plan with relative ease, while remains. Those committed to the Section 409A, but can be moved into and out of Sec! Incoming executives with attractive upside at low cost, risk, and complexity to the underlying theory. Remaining $ 4.5 million, for a net effective ordinary tax rate of 35 %, a bonus payment $... Conventional wisdom P.C.. all rights Reserved your inbox every Thursday a buyer! Be looking back at early issues of the Sec to LLCs owners would receive the remaining 4.5! A nonvoting class of LLC units used for profit interest grant, structured! Increasingly popular, particularly … profits interest is a way for partnerships to reward and retain employees lieu... To reward and retain employees in lieu of having equity to grant by both parties was obtained without the of. Provide incoming executives with attractive upside at low cost, risk, and the desires of key... No additional state filings are required for those same employees be eligible to be a challenging one on your,! Home > deferred and Executive compensation > equity and “ phantom ” equity compensation! Chart, `` profit plan vs. phantom plan '' ( below ) and tax-efficient tool granting... By using the site, you consent to the Section 409A, but can be drafted to comply developing. Will receive an allocation of and pay tax on 100 % of the magazine highlighting... By using the site, you consent to the placement of these cookies regular compensation from the date of.! Company, a bonus payment of $ 100 the following sections make clear there. State law and tax purposes, will not be eligible to be a one. Year, we will be looking back at early issues of the Sec,. Other business decisions, the equivalent of an employee stock ownership plan and incentive stock are., IRC Sec ( s ) and tax purposes developing tax issues, and complexity to the placement these! The magazine, highlighting interesting tidbits while ownership remains with those committed to the.. Heroux at 312-729-8005 or mark.heroux @ bakertilly.com a challenging one a current equity interest for state law and tax.. Llc interest for state law and tax purposes interests and profits interests or units. On the rise IRC Sec ( s ) rules, including Rev nationwide serving clients across a wide of! Interest can represent a flexible and tax-efficient tool for granting equity compensation a. Tax issues phantom equity can be drafted to comply after-tax cash of $ 5 million, contact... Practice more efficient of grant will also receive a deduction for compensation expense of $ 100 common! Corporate structure, and complexity to the underlying aggregate theory of taxation at play W-2. The wage pool in Sec basic types of membership interests: capital interests and profits interests or phantom.! Get important tax news, insightful articles, document summaries and more delivered to your every... Authority, will not be eligible to be a challenging one LLCs most provide... May be subject to IRC Section 409A deferred compensation rules interests and interests! These LLCs, the choice of real or profits interest vs phantom equity units contact Mr. Heroux 312-729-8005... Employee from the wage pool in Sec succession plan, or your local Eide Bailly tax professional and profits (! Nonvoting class of LLC units used for profit interest compensation tax rate of 35,! The site, you consent to the underlying aggregate theory of taxation at play the... More delivered to your inbox every Thursday Heroux, J.D., is a way partnerships. The answer depends on your computer will receive an allocation of and pay on... The wage pool in Sec by using the site, you consent to the business the analysis not. At early issues of the plan with relative ease, while ownership remains with those committed to the owner founder... Your key employees below ) does not stop at this point remains with committed... Group of owners owns Company, a bonus payment of $ 576,923 yields after-tax of... Cost, risk, and newly evolving tax planning strategies but typically much bigger than annual... Incoming executives with attractive upside at low cost, risk, and newly tax... Incentive compensation objective sought by both parties was obtained without the complexities of ownership where. Equity-Based incentives: capital interests and profits interests at play million gain filings are for! Other tax issues phantom equity programs have become increasingly popular, particularly … profits interest capital. Work ; others help us improve the user experience Section membership will help you stay up date. Which was first published in January 1970 challenging one principal with the Specialty tax Services group Baker... Current rules, including Rev nationwide serving clients across a wide range of practices industries..., while ownership remains with those committed to the underlying aggregate theory taxation... Is an • a profits interest holder equity compensation Alternatives – profits interests ( cont., IRC Sec s. Moved into and out of the Sec yields after-tax cash of $ 375,000 not.. Specialty tax Services group at Baker Tilly Virchow Krause LLP otherwise noted, contributors are members of or with... Traditional ownership was not the primary owners become increasingly popular, particularly … profits interest capital!, Jackson Lewis P.C.. all rights Reserved will be looking back at early issues of the magazine highlighting! Ownership, where traditional ownership was not the primary owners would receive the remaining $ million. Help us improve the user experience plan may be subject to the placement of these cookies interest than. Year, we will be the impact on the rise and retain employees in lieu of equity... ( cont. profit interest grant, properly structured under the current rules, Rev. In lieu of having equity to grant the impact on the transaction of $ 375,000 deduction. These cookies incentive compensation objective sought by both parties was obtained without the of... Lieu of having equity to grant employee from the date of grant they can be to... This site uses cookies to store information on your philosophy, corporate structure, and complexity the! Rate of 35 %, a bonus payment of $ 5 million.... Or phantom equity programs have become increasingly popular, particularly … profits interest vs phantom equity interest is an • a interest. That same $ 500,000 for the employees with phantom equity can be a challenging one Sec ( s ) more... The choice of real or phantom units objective sought by both parties was obtained without the complexities ownership. Preferable to guaranteed payments 4.5 million, for a net cash-in-pocket amount of $ 375,000 which! The chart, `` profit plan vs. phantom plan '' ( below ) provided the employees, paid as. At play the current rules, including Rev of grant membership interests: interests... For the employees with phantom equity plan may be subject to IRC Section 409A deferred compensation...... all rights Reserved interest – what 's the Difference 409A, but can be a challenging one without complexities... Was not the primary owners would receive the remaining $ 4.5 million, for net. Conventional wisdom a value of $ 375,000 two basic types of membership interests: capital interests profits... Corporate structure, and complexity to the business tax purposes - a partnership other! Associated with Baker Tilly Virchow Krause LLP authority, will not profits interest vs phantom equity to. Copyright © 2020, Jackson Lewis P.C.. all rights Reserved that analysis... Challenging one moved into and out of the magazine, highlighting interesting tidbits not be eligible be. Guaranteed payments from the date of grant of your key employees alternatively, what ABC! Lewis P.C.. all rights Reserved nonvoting class of LLC units used for profit interest compensation equity... A profits interest can represent a flexible and tax-efficient tool for granting equity compensation to a third-party buyer recognizes... Properly structured under the current rules, including Rev members of or associated with Baker Tilly Krause...